In a Realm Beyond all Comprehension: PNB's "Ghost Stories", Round Two

In a string of shadowed works, Pacific Northwest Ballet’s recent quadruple bill, “Ghost Stories” is an example of the vast ways in which dance can reach us. Be it in the abstract renderings of heart-strung emotions, in the technical feat of athletic verve, or in the profundity of a wordless story moving us beyond comprehension, such broad repertory touches us in inexplicable ways.
Opening a program with a ballet by Alejandro Cerrudo always manages to sweep away the cares of the world in an instant. In the moods he weaves, and the evocations of the human spirit that flood the stage, Cerrudo has such sensitivity to the human condition. It might even be fair to say that Cerrudo is one of the few choreographers who knows the power of simplicity, and who understands how to touch an audience in ways even we cannot describe.
It was during the second weekend of Silent Ghost that I realized that being able to feel the inner motion of a work is a rare quality that arises prominently in Cerrudo’s work. There is something about his use of repetition, his momentum guided by an inner compass, that translates the texture of the score into visceral motion. Technically, watching any dance activates our mirror neurons, but with Cerrudo this effect is particularly tangible; the gentle stirrings of limb and soul carve their way through us until the rounded flow is palpable. This kinesthetic experience leads us to empathy even when we cannot explain why the ephemeral forms before us call forth such a response.
Cerrudo is also a master of drawing us into the meditation of slowed, purposeful motion, and only once he breaks this spell do we realize how deeply invested we were in the minuscule inner breath of the moment (like at the end of the first pas de deux, when a dancer seems to cut another from their life source, and the sudden slice of black is a shocking effect). In a similar way that Cerrudo’s One Thousand Pieces exists in a continuum, Silent Ghost fades in and out of vignettes as though in a dream with an undercurrent of undying momentum.
Before the premiere of Silent Ghost in 2015, Cerrudo was asked about the meaning of the work and replied: “If there need to be any answers — they’re found onstage”. That is the beauty of such a work: each time it falls with new breath, there is a different lens placed before it, for we take from it what we need. There are gestures to decipher, even a possible story or metaphoric rendering, but above all, there is simply the task to feel. To let it gift you what it will. Wash over and declare what it can, and what it must.
Cerrudo brings us from the outer world to a higher plane by beginning with intensely physical, inventive dynamics that soften to a whisper only three minutes into the work. There the work lingers in heavenly light falling upon time-suspended forms: wings dropped like a breath, the drive of a hand pushing through thickened air, casual gesture launching into urgent desire like the truth at once unraveling; two souls turning to face the other with a tenderness that feels almost too intimate to perceive.
I’ve said it before, but let me stress again what a difference it makes to witness movement that is so fully realized. The long-established relationships with Cerrudo’s language are evident in the way dancers inhabit his work. Elle Macy has crawled within the language of Silent Ghost; she has claimed every nook. The specificity of her placement, the intention behind the softest of gestures, the power distilled within such quiet motion, and her inner propulsion through the work is an endlessly stirring sight.
Leah Terada, like a coiling ribbon through the dark, has a beautiful human fragility that reveals and evokes a waterfall of impression even amidst the work’s most strenuous demands.
Dylan Wald, with his laser-focused gaze and swift step, is so centered within the work that it seems as though he’s never known any world beyond this hazy darkness. His unearthly control alone–pressing up from the earth with Terada perched upon his back, not to mention a host of other Cerrudian inventions–seems to balance on the precipice of reality itself.
To name a few more lovely sights: Melisa Guilliams’ sharpened arrow of a foot piercing the dark, the softened core of Christopher D’Ariano’s being, and Joh Morill’s endless reach painting the ebony canvas he inhabits.
Cerrudo tends to end his ballets with one final, climbing pas de deux, and Silent Ghost is no different. Though it doesn’t build to the drama of Little Mortal Jump, there is still the kind of slowly built momentum that makes it feel like they could go on forever and we would sit there tethered to the lulling piano and ceaseless motion until the end of time. But an end does come. She abandons the scene and leaves him standing there before us, head bowed, arms lifted heavenward, a strangely moving image of human fragility as the curtain falls.

Speaking of humanness, Pacopepepluto is a singing little gem of the uninhibited human spirit. With signature Cerrudo fluidity coursing through the golden-streaked dark, it exists within the hazy same world as Silent Ghost, but these three visitors are of vastly different temperaments. They are not weighed down by their own existence; they are only there to play, and this element of play is what shapes the work. Pacopepepluto demands fully-embodied, unapologetic motion. It is built upon a dynamic inner rhythm, one which sinks into an image, only to burst forth anew with flashes of blink-and-you’ll-miss-it movement. During the final performance of the rep, it became quite clear: Pacopepepluto is a fleeting vision of three guys in love with life itself.
Whenever such a nostalgic voice spurs on a work, there’s always the impulse to cling more dearly to the present moment as it flits by; to cling to the visions that fill the night as they never will again. Mark Cudihee’s long limbs elongating the musical intonations of flowing strength; Christopher D’Ariano’s human inflections and infectious energy; and Jonathan Batista darting towards the moon; Joh Morrill, nearly delirious with uninhibited freedom and love-struck urgency; and of course, Dylan Wald proving once again his Apollonian nature as flashes of gold sailed through the dark–larger than life and surging with strength–a portrait of his artistry in every cathartic breath.
Not since the premiere of PNB’s newly-constructed Sleeping Beauty has a dress rehearsal crowd responded so eagerly to a new vision unfolding upon McCaw Hall’s stage. Kyle Davis’ world premiere of The Raven is not only a tour de force for piano, it is a tour de force of dance, of character, and of vision. In seven far-too-brief performances, The Raven continued to prove what was already apparent at dress rehearsal: PNB is sitting on a gold mine of choreographic talent, pushing the craft of wordless storytelling towards its future while retaining the beauty of its past.
It is always a testament to the caliber of a work when it still greets you with newly illuminated brilliances after two weekends of performances. In eighteen minutes, Davis manages to condense not only the essence of Edgar Allan Poe’s verse, but also infuses it with his own poetry, building metaphor and symbolism that extend the ballet far beyond its bounds.
The use of Lenore’s scarf as both choreographic tool and multi-use storyteller is particularly poetic. At curtain’s rise, we find them both wrapped up together within its length until she slips away, and she is continuously fleeting from its gauzy hold until, in a guttural return to reality, the man finds it empty. Throughout the ballet, this metaphysical veil is at once a noose, a binding thread, a shawl, and a haunting remainder of love that lets Lenore evaporate before our eyes.
Emma Kingsbury’s costume designs also add layers of meaning if eyes are sharp enough to catch it. When Lenore returns after the Raven’s arrival, she has lost the top layer of her skirt, revealing intricate lace which, quite brilliantly, makes her less physically tangible as she begins to slip from the Poet’s grasp. In placing this intangible memory figure upon the stage, Davis shows us something rarely seen, namely the other side of grief. As memory unspools in the present, we witness Lenore’s turmoil of losing her love through her own death, and Davis’ rendering is hauntingly evocative in its urgency.

In a time when the majority of world premieres lean towards contemporary and neoclassical vocabularies, witnessing a freshly-born endeavor which carries a classical heritage is an immense treat. Davis’ choreography is informed by both the rigors of classical ballet and the daring extension of neoclassical and contemporary vocabularies that blend into a technically demanding feat. The intensity of the partnering alone, and the interactions of such individual choreographic language for each of the three characters, is still, after two weekends, a shock of invention. Recognizable gestures of the Romantic era, like the Giselle-like overhead press (from a kneel!), the willowy port de bra and ghostly bourrées place the tale firmly within the 1840s, while allowing grief to wilt the edges of their form and the Raven to grow into a beast of ferocious pointe work.
In The Raven, Davis has crafted a striking character that no words ever could have chiseled. Nor could each flicker of the Raven be more perfectly formed to the defining gifts of Sarah-Gabrielle Ryan’s artistry. Her authority turns the room into a palace, with a cunning glance and an electrically charged presence even in her stillness. There are some roles that, from their first impression, become permanently imprinted with one dancer’s vividness, and this one is unforgettably forever Ryan’s own: all sharp ferocity and brilliantly gleaming spirit.
Just as the Raven makes me yearn to see Ryan take on Odile, Lenore makes it clear what physical devotion Clara Ruf Maldonado would bring to the dramatic role of Manon, or to the ethereality of Giselle. Her tender-hearted Lenore is deeply musically attuned, and the weight of loss is so real in her eyes that we believe every grief-wallowed breath. Likewise, Angelica Generosa’s sensitivity to her dear poet, the urgency in her steps, and her delirium as she wilts before our eyes is a startling portrayal in its truth.
Christopher D’Ariano left it all upon the stage during this run of The Raven. He cannot believe his eyes; he is lost in thought, with swift steps sweeping across the bounds of the stage as though it cannot contain his grief. We feel his agitation as much as we see it, and watching him grow feverishly unwell, truly tortured by the Raven, was painfully real each and every time.
What Dylan Wald brings to The Raven is, like what we were lucky enough to witness in his Romeo, an utterly unique ability to seemingly bare his entire soul when he comes into motion. The way he consumes space with his serene carriage, the way his entire body can become hallowed by grief, his needle-sharp axis and control; simply the strength in his port de bra and poetic gestures…there will never be enough words to capture any of the augustness that floods this stage.
In eighteen brief minutes, we become so entangled in their tale that watching that curtain fall is like closing a book before you’re ready for the chapter to be over. One can only hope that with Davis’ impending retirement, we will soon get to see more from this most considerate and detailed of choreographers.
Amidst his catalogue of over four hundred works, La Sonnambula is hardly thought to be George Balanchine’s most brilliant, but, as Allen Hughes wrote in a 1965 review: "if it were the product of almost any other choreographer, it would probably qualify as one of that creator's masterpieces. It combines drama, divertissement, characterization and color with extraordinary dexterity and smoothness, and does it with astonishing fidelity”.
Less than six months post-war, La Sonnambula (then called Night Shadow) was choreographed on the road as the Ballet Russe de Monte Carlo traversed the United States. Though Vittorio Rieti’s commissioned score is based on the themes of Vincenzo Bellini’s La Sonnambula and i Puritani, it does not take the plot of Bellini’s opera, rather, Rieti had written a scenario inspired by Bellini’s actual life: a jealous husband who had attempted to poison him. To this scenario, Balanchine made two changes. Firstly, he introduced the character of Coquette in order to give the ballet two ballerinas (fittingly mirroring his own life, for his former love Alexandra Danilova was the original Sleepwalker, and the Coquette was performed by his new obsession, the promising young Maria Tallchief). Additionally, he changed the ending, leaving his Sleepwalker asleep even as she seems to gain an uncanny consciousness in mourning.
The wonderful thing about dance is that we don’t always know why a particular work moves us. In the case of La Sonnambula, the wonderfully strange events which form the ballet are not individually profound elements: the Baron’s orchestration of the meeting of his mistress, the Coquette, and the Poet; the three divertissements which do nothing for the plot, yet seem to tilt on the edge of something far greater; the surrealist scene after the Poet’s death when the divertissement dancers rush back onstage with their hair down and join the ball dancers in a stylized, theatrical mourning; and of course, the fundamental configuration of merriment surrounding scenes of an elevated plane of existence. It is somehow this lack of harmony that gives La Sonnambula its intriguing and unexpected potency.
When it first premiered in 1946, the dancers at the ball were cloaked in surrealist headdresses: animal heads, clocks, bulbous abstract shapes, and collaged materials that created quite a different sense of reality than the ballroom that we see today. Frederic Franklin, on whom the role of the Poet was created, referred to these costumes as “bizarre”, and remembered that “the curtain went up and the audience really was stunned; it didn’t know quite what to make of this whole ballet”. Bathed in the original green-hued light, the atmosphere of Night Shadow was a surrealist Gothic scene for an American public who couldn’t always afford to come to the ballet, but came anyway.
Balanchine undertook the task of addressing the essential elements of a classical story ballet in just thirty minutes, tossing in humor at whim (the first Harlequin was a woman, Marie-Jeanne Pelus, whose mimed back pain and grumbling were supposedly inspired by Pelus’ real-life behavior in class each day), and placing the sublime beside the earthly felicity of the corps de ballet. Particularly in the polonaise, there’s an element of The Sleeping Beauty in both sound and mood, which, of course, Balanchine could not deny (he even included the game of blind man’s bluff, also seen in The Sleeping Beauty). Though we get entangled in the pleasure of these light-hearted festivities, it is all an elaborate build-up for the Sleepwalker’s distinction from the Poet’s shallow society.

Like the sylphs and wilis who filled the Romantic era of ballet, the Sleepwalker is another woman in white who leads a mortal man astray. But Balanchine was less so purposefully recalling these images than simply tracing the story of La Sonnambula back to its roots. The 1946 ballet borrows themes from Bellini’s 1831 opera, and Bellini’s opera was inspired by the scenario of Eugène Scribe’s 1827 ballet, which, five years before La Sylphide and fourteen years before Giselle, capitalized on the popularity of stories about the phenomenon of sleepwalking. Reflecting on this, Lincoln Kirstein wrote, “The ballerina as sleepwalker afforded a psychological extension of histrionics, at once realistic and Romantic…it tapped mysteries of the unconscious mind.”
The Sleepwalker’s innocence lies in contrast to the sensual lust of the Coquette, and these qualities reflect in the character of their interactions with the Poet. Each shares a pas de deux with him, yet they could not be more different. The Coquette’s is closely entangled in a tantalizing swell of near-constant physical contact, while the Sleepwalker’s is full of space, defined by the longing that fills so many Balanchine ballets. Alexandra Danilova reflected: “I was going toward the moon. And that attracts the Poet, because he can’t make contact with this woman. That is the enigma of this ballet. He senses her understanding of his poetry.”
Discussions of La Sonnambula often focus their efforts on interpretations of the Sleepwalker, but as Nancy Goldner keenly notes in Balanchine Variations, as the original Coquette, Maria Tallchief “brought such sensuous energy to the role that she made the duet with the Poet important.” Eighty years later, Sarah-Gabrielle Ryan does the same thing. The character simply radiates from her, and in a rep that truly highlights her as a scintillating storyteller, the details of her Coquette, her épaulement and the way she carries herself, are glorious.
Amidst her pas de deux with Kyle Davis’ Poet, it may have been possible to momentarily forget the promised Sleepwalker, for they sink into the full swell of this amorous entanglement with velvet underfoot. Their lush abundance is draped in an intoxication of drama and longing, and though they’ve been paired together in many gems (Giselle, Nine Sinatra Songs, Dawn Patrol, Coppélia), this brief enchantment might just be the most splendid of all.
Davis’ poet is entirely enamored. During the Sleepwalker pas de deux, everyone may have been watching the Sleepwalker’s eyes, but I was watching his, for the all-consuming adoration and sensitivity that filled them were a wordless story in themselves. Winsome and attentive, his investment in the moment is ever more a potent revelation.
In the Balanchine canon, La Sonnambula stands alone in what it achieves through such un-Balanchinian methods. If we were to strip it down to its core, it is still made of the material that fills the majority of Balanchine’s ballets, namely the longing of a man for an unattainable female. The Poet’s pas de deux with the Sleepwalker begins in astonishment. He is utterly perplexed by this being who dashes across the stage with remarkable urgency, yet refuses to respond to him in any fashion. He is under a spell as the score declares the epiphany of being able to make contact with her, and thus begins their strange encounter, first led by her own will, soon moved only by his hands upon her heart, pushing her gently across the stage like a breeze in her sails. The perceived simplicity of their pas de deux relies not only on the lightest flicker of steps, but on the presentation of what lies behind those sleeping eyes. As Nancy Goldner notes, “how unusual it is that a choreographer famous for directing his dancers to just do the steps relies in this ballet on a dancer’s ability to project an inner life”.
Clara Ruf Maldonado is as light as a feather as she barely grazes the ground. A will-o'-the-wisp in her delicacy, she nonetheless holds a storm within her emptied eyes. A weightless arabesque, the speed of her bourrée courree, the sensitivity of the slightest breeze stirring her limb…all inform the otherworldlyness of her Sleepwalker, but it is the depth of loss that floods her being as the Poet is placed in her arms that lingers most hauntingly.
Drawn by some unseen force, Madison Rayn Abeo’s Sleepwalker is bewitching from the first glance. With glassy, unblinking eyes that paint her from another realm, she is made of air and heavenly drift. In a run of three Sleepwalkers, Abeo’s is markedly bathed in an eerie air, for her own image is altered by the steadfastness of her carriage. Through flouried bourrées, and the lyricism of the smallest of wafts, there it still is, recalling reflections of Allegra Kent’s own Sleepwalker: “an inner turmoil made of iron…upset frozen in time, her body on the threshold of evaporation” (Nancy Goldner).
La Sonnambula was last seen on this stage nearly twenty years ago, mere months before Patricia Barker’s retirement. Its principal roles were then filled by Barker, Ariana Lellone, Olivier Wevers, Louise Nadeau, and Jonathan Poretta, to name a few illuminated names. Watching a new generation take on its iconic roles is to know that in twenty years' time, we’ll be looking back at these November evenings with the same kind of reverence.
Even after two weekends, watching the Sleepwalker’s light traverse one final time is a strangely devastating blow. Its effect still mysterious, its haunting depth of mood still in the evening air long after Bellini’s melancholy has faded.
The run may be over, but “Ghost Stories” streams through Monday, November 23rd. Don’t miss out! https://www.pnb.org/season/subscriptions/




Comments